Go Back Email Link
+ servings
Fuss Free Flavours

Find more recipes at fussfreeflavours.com

Close up of a wooden board with two slices of bread spread with sandwich spread
4.84 from 12 votes

Easy Homemade Sandwich Spread

This homemade sandwich spread recipe is tangy, creamy and crunchy, and will transport you straight back to childhood picnics on the beach. Enjoy it in sandwich or as a dip,
Servings: 8 servings
Cook Time10 minutes

Ingredients

Sandwich Spread Sauce

  • 3 tbs mayonnaise - full fat
  • 3 tbs salad cream
  • 2 tsp pickle vinegar
  • 1 tsp English mustard - or other smooth mustard to taste

Vegetables (About one generous cup in total once chopped)

  • 1 stick celery
  • 6 small gherkins
  • 1 small carrot
  • ½ bell pepper
  • 1 tbs capers
  • 2 spring onions
  • Other crunchy, non watery vegetables of choice

Instructions

  • Put the mayonnaise, salad cream and mustard into a medium mixing bowl, along with 2 teaspoons of vinegar from the jar of gherkins or pickles and mix well. 
  • Prepare the vegetable by peeling, cutting into thin batons and then dicing finely.
    They need to be small, but not so fine they don't have any texture.
  • Add the diced vegetables to the mayonnaise mixture, season with pepper and salt and mix well.
  • Store in a jar in the fridge and use within 3 days.

Notes

How long does sandwich spread keep? 
Up to three days in a sealed jar in the fridge. 
The spread will get a bit thinner after a day or so as the water comes out of the vegetables.  
How can I change the flavour? 
You can mix up the vegetables to suit what you have available and to take account of personal preferences. I think that the celery, gherkins and carrot are essential, but beyond that you can mix it up and even add some crunchy fruit! Just don't use watery salad vegetables like cucumber or tomatoes. 
For an upmarket variation, try adding a pinch of cayenne pepper for some heat, and/or a generous amount of chopped fresh herbs. Parsley, dill or coriander (cilantro) would all be delicious.  
Include other non-watery vegetables in season to taste: 
  • radishes
  • kohlrabi
  • asparagus 
  • crunchy apple 
  • green beans
• Please note that the nutrition information provided below is approximate and meant as a guideline only.
• Unless stated otherwise cup conversions have been made with an online tool. For accuracy please check with your favoured conversion tool. We recommend buying inexpensive digital kitchen scales.