Fresh and vibrant, sharp and sweet, homemade mint sauce is the easiest of recipes and will give your Sunday lunch a real lift.
Homemade Mint Sauce – A British Classic
Mint sauce is a British classic and it pairs perfectly with roast lamb, for a classic British Sunday roast.
Lamb is a fatty meat. Less so than in years gone by due to modern farming methods, but it still needs a little astringency and our grandmothers knew what they were doing. The sharpness of mint sauce cuts through it perfectly.
The combination of the sweet lamb with fresh herby tang of the mint, sour vinegar and a little sugar all produce one of those wonderous culinary effects that is greater than the sum of its parts.
It is very easy and so much better when it’s fresh, and homemade mint sauce couldn’t be easier to make.
Making mint sauce at home also avoid the strange dyes and preservatives added to some of the bought versions, so do try making your own.
The secret to good mint sauce is to keep some texture in the mint, whilst extracting as much flavour as you can. In this mint sauce recipe, I’ve got a couple of helpful tricks to do this, taught to me by my mother.
The British Love Lamb!
We eat lots of lamb here in the UK and it always surprises me that in North America it hardly seems to feature at all. But sheep farming is a traditional way of life here, especially in the exposed hilly regions of Wales and the far north of England, and lamb is essential to our food heritage.
A roast is probably my favourite way to serve. New season spring lamb, slowly roasted, is the classic Easter lunch. Easter without lamb would be like Christmas without turkey and Easter lamb without mint sauce would be all wrong.
Once past its first flush of youth, lamb responds well to long slow cooking which tenderises and brings out the flavour.
Many of our traditional British dishes use lamb or mutton that has been slowly cooked, warming, comforting, “rib sticking”, affordable food, perfect for the long dark cold winter nights. Dishes like Lancashire hot pot, lamb stews, shepherd’s pie…
Of course, lamb (or goat) is also key to the food of the Eastern Mediterranean and the Indian subcontinent, so it fills our imported takeaway menus too. There, the mint sauce is made with yogurt and chilli rather than vinegar, but we still can’t get enough of it!
Mint Sauce Recipe – Ingredients
- Fresh Mint – You want regular common garden mint (mentha spicata) for this, not fierce peppermint or the fancy varieties that are supposed to taste of chocolate or pineapple. There are lots of subspecies so don’t worry if your garden mint looks darker and pointier than mine!
Mint is remarkably easy and fast to grow and spreads like wildfire. Plant some, but keep it in a container so it doesn’t take over in the garden. Keep cutting it to keep the fresh, soft leaves coming, and cut it right back at the end of autumn for fresh growth in spring.
- Sugar – I use plain white granulated sugar. You can use caster sugar, but everyday sugar is just fine.
- Vinegar – I usually use white wine vinegar, because it is sharp enough to stand out against the sugar, but not too astringent. I prefer a white vinegar as it doesn’t make your mint sauce a murky colour (You can also use a cider vinegar). Malt vinegar is just too strong and sharp and will overpower the flavour of the mint. Some people like to give an Italian note and add a splash of balsamic, but I’m not convinced.
How to Make Mint Sauce – Recipe Step-by-Step
Step One – Grab the ingredients. If you are using freshly cut mint rather than supermarket leaves, pick the mint over thoroughly.
Step Two – Strip all the leaves off the stalks.
Step Three – Put the mint leaves on a chopping board, sprinkle the sugar over, and then chop finely. The sugar adds some abrasion and makes it easier to get a fine cut, as well as starting to release the flavour.
You can also pack the leaves and sugar into a mug and use a pair of scissors to chop (the mug holds it all together nicely and makes the chopping a breeze). I use regular kitchen scissors. I have tried those multi-bladed herb scissors and found them to be a waste of time, money and drawer space.
Step Four – Once chopped, transfer to a small bowl or jug. Pour a little boiling water over and give the mint a good bash with the end of a wooden spoon. This will help to bring out the flavour and to dissolve the sugar.
Step Five – Stir in the vinegar and let the sauce sit for the flavours to develop and meld before serving with roast lamb.
Can I Use a Blender or Food Processor?
NO!!!! Blending or using a food processor will pulp the mint. You want small pieces of mint floating in the vinegar.
Mint Sauce Hints & Tips
- Use regular ingredients, not the fancy versions – common garden mint, and regular granulated sugar.
- Chop the mint finely, but do not puree it.
- Give that mint a good pounding to extract the flavour.
- Use white wine vinegar or, at a pinch, cider vinegar. Malt or pickling vinegar is far too powerful and will overwhelm the mint.
- Make your sauce a good hour in advance, to allow the flavours to develop and serve at room temperature.
When to Serve Mint Sauce
- Homemade mint sauce is delicious with roast lamb.
- It’s equally delicious with leftover cold lamb, or other cold cuts.
- Leftover mint sauce can be used on the next day’s new potatoes, or as a salad dressing. It is especially good with chickpeas or shredded courgettes.
- Mix it with marrowfat peas to make minty mushy peas.
- Mix into natural yogurt to make a cooling dip for Indian food, or add a little chilli too for something spicy.
- You can also use this mint sauce in my kebab shop chilli sauce.
More great sauce recipes
If you like this recipe, here are more great sauce ideas:
- Chilli sauce
- Garlic sauce
- Peri peri sauce
- Allioli – Catalan garlic sauce
- Blue cheese sauce for steak
- Chinese curry sauce
Easy Mint Sauce
Ingredients
- 1 handful fresh mint (1 cup)
- 1 ½ tbsp sugar
- 3 tbsp boiling water
- 2 tbsp white wine vinegar
Instructions
- Strip the mint leaves from the stalks. Keep the leaves and discard the stalks.
- Place the mint leaves on a chopping board. Add the sugar. Chop with a knife until all the mint is cut into small pieces.
- Transfer the mint and sugar mixture to a small bowl. Add the boiling water, and mix together, using the handle of a wooden spoon to give the mint a gentle pound to extract the flavour.
- Add the vinegar and mix together. Leave to stand for an hour to allow the flavours to blend.
Notes
- Use regular ingredients – common fresh mint, standard granulated sugar, and plain white wine or cider vinegar. I find malt or pickling vinegar too harsh.
- Chop the mint finely, but do not puree it.
- Give that mint a good pounding to extract the flavour.
- This recipe is 1 Weight Watchers Smart Points per portion
Riya
I tried making mint sauce so many times but everytime i failed bringing the perfect restaurant taste… But, your recipe has the accurate measurement of ingredients… I tried it and I have finally made the perfect mint sauce ever.. thanks for sharing.
Helen
So pleased you like it!
Monica Elizabeth
This really is just right to have with lamb. I didn’t realise it was so easy and much prefer this to anything you find in a jar.
Helen
It really is easy to make, you’ll never buy from a jar again.
Donna G
I really like making mint yogurt sauce for chicken, but this could be my new favourite. So simple and so delicious, perfect with lamb.
Helen
So so good with lamb.
Penny
Lamb is my favourite kind of roast, and the mint sauce is the perfect finishing touch. Great idea to make your own, so much flavour.
Helen
The flavour is really good isn’t it.
Trevor Ball
Easy to make this sauce up as the rest of the dinner cooks. Was a lovely addition to the meal.
Helen
The perfect finishing touch.
Moira
There is something rather wonderful about going out to pick mint leaves from your garden and making this. I love the fresh smell you get pounding the leaves. And utterly delicious with dinner!
Helen
It is such a lovely smell.
Vivien Ellis
My children like to eat mint sauce with just about everything, not just lamb. So I do tend to go through a lot. Making it from scratch is no hassle and so much better.
Helen
It is so very easy to make.
Amelia Jenkin
This really does make the loveliest mint sauce, and so good with roast leg of lamb. One of my favourite Sunday meals.
Helen
Roast lamb is one of my favourites too.
Julia
Love mint sauce and this recipe is just right for the perfect accompaniment for a Sunday roast.
Helen
Perfect to go with lamb.
Sadie Porter
Such a flavorsome sauce and the smell is wonderful. It made our roast lamb dinner extra special.
Helen
So glad you enjoyed it.
Felicity D
Lamb needs mint sauce, it goes so well together. This sauce is just the thing and the fresh mint flavour is so good.
Helen
Fresh mint is so lovely.
Keira Ball
Will going to cook it tonight. Looks like easy and tasty.
Helen
Easy and delicious.
Brenda
You are completely right Helen, the flavours of mint and lamb is one of those combinations that were made to go together. The fresh mint in your homemade sauce is just perfect.
Helen
The fresh mint is so tasty.
connie
Wonderfully fresh and tasty, and so very easy to make. A must have with roast lamb.
Helen
Perfect for roast lamb.
Lisa Dodds
The fresh mint is so delicious and makes the sauce taste wonderful.
Helen
So good to use fresh.
Bryan B
I never thought of the reason why mint is good with lamb, now I know. Great, easy to make sauce.
Helen
So very good together.
Kate
Can I substitute the sugar with coconut sugar or honey?
Helen
Hi Kate, I think it would throw the flavour off – possibly the coconut sugar – but I’ve never used it.
Sheila
How long will this keep for please
Helen
A couple of days in the fridge, but it really is best made fresh the day you want to use it.
Dawn
I’ve not made this yet but I’m going to, I’m on my own and wondered if it could be kept in a sealed jar for a length of time ?
Helen Best-Shaw
I wouldn’t recommend keeping it for more than a few days in the fridge. You can portion in an ice cube tray and freeze, but the mint will loose its colour.
James
Simple x 2: simple to make and simply delicious! Thanks for sharing.
Helen Best-Shaw
Perfect. thank you for commenting
Jenny
This recipe is awesome – comes out perfect every time and is just like the mint sauce I had as a kid growing up in the UK. Love it! Thank you!
Helen Best-Shaw
Fantastic. I am thrilled you love it!